If your business runs on Microsoft 365, Microsoft Authenticator (backed by Microsoft Entra ID) is usually the simplest, cheapest way to get multi-factor authentication (MFA) working. If you have a mix of VPNs, non-Microsoft apps and varied devices, or you want one MFA layer across all of them, Cisco Duo earns its subscription. The catch is that the two are not like for like. Authenticator is an app. Duo is a whole access-security service. This guide compares them properly, with UK prices, so you can decide without a sales call.
Key takeaways
- Microsoft Authenticator is a free app; the controls around it (Conditional Access, reporting, risk policies) come from Microsoft Entra ID, which is where the real comparison with Duo sits.
- Basic MFA is included in Microsoft 365 subscriptions at no extra cost. Entra ID P1 is £5.40 and P2 £7.70 per user per month, paid yearly.
- Duo has a free tier for up to 10 users, then paid tiers listed in US dollars ($3, $6 and $9 per user per month), so budget for exchange rates and VAT.
- You can run Duo on top of Microsoft 365 as an external MFA provider, but you cannot swap Microsoft Authenticator in for Duo Mobile everywhere.
- For most small Microsoft-only teams, start with Microsoft. Choose Duo when your estate is mixed or you need its device and network controls.
Table of Contents
- Why this comparison is trickier than it looks
- What each option is
- Side-by-side comparison
- Features and administration
- Can you use them together?
- What it costs a UK small business
- Disadvantages to weigh
- Which one should you choose?
- How to roll out MFA without locking yourself out
- Where Solusec fits
- FAQ
- Sources
Why this comparison is trickier than it looks
Search for "Duo vs Microsoft Authenticator" and you will find side-by-side software review tools and vendor forum threads. Most of them compare a mobile app with a security platform, which is a bit like comparing a car key with a car.
Microsoft describes Authenticator as a free smartphone app that approves sign-ins, generates one-time codes and offers passwordless sign-in with a fingerprint, face recognition or PIN. It works with personal, work and school accounts. In a business, though, Microsoft positions it as one authentication method inside Entra ID. Entra ID is the part that lets administrators choose which methods are allowed, set Conditional Access rules and see who is signing in from where.
Duo, by contrast, is a security-first identity and access platform that includes its own MFA, its own app (Duo Mobile), a directory and identity intelligence. So the fair question is not "which app?" but "Entra ID with Authenticator, or Duo with Duo Mobile?"
What each option is
Microsoft Authenticator with Entra ID
Entra ID is Microsoft's cloud identity service, formerly Azure Active Directory. If you have seen "Azure MFA" mentioned in older guides, this is it, renamed. Authenticator supports push notifications, passwordless phone sign-in and OATH codes, and Microsoft's UK documentation says the app meets NIST Authenticator Assurance Level 2 requirements. Administrators can control which methods are available, and Microsoft advises enabling more than one so users can recover access.
Duo and Duo Mobile
Duo sells MFA as a subscription in four editions. According to Cisco's editions page:
- Essentials includes Duo Directory, phishing-resistant MFA, passwordless authentication, single sign-on, trusted endpoints and unlimited applications.
- Advantage adds identity intelligence, session-theft protection, Active Directory Defense and risk-based authentication.
- Premier adds VPN-less access to private resources and complete device trust, including the Duo Network Gateway for on-premises or multi-cloud resources.
There is also a Free edition for up to 10 users, and a 30-day free trial of the paid plans.
Side-by-side comparison
| Microsoft Authenticator + Entra ID | Duo | |
|---|---|---|
| What you buy | Free app; admin controls via Microsoft 365 or Entra ID licences | Subscription per user, per month |
| Entry cost | Basic MFA included in Microsoft 365 | Free for up to 10 users |
| Paid tiers | Entra ID P1 £5.40, P2 £7.70 per user per month, paid yearly | Essentials $3, Advantage $6, Premier $9 per user per month |
| Passwordless | Yes, via phone sign-in | Yes, from Essentials |
| Policy engine | Conditional Access (P1 and above) | Policies in the Duo admin panel |
| Risk-based access | P2 | Advantage and above |
| Strongest fit | Microsoft 365-centred businesses | Mixed apps, VPNs and devices |
| Works with the other? | Duo can act as an external provider for Entra ID | Duo Mobile is needed for some Duo integrations |
Prices are from Microsoft's UK Entra ID page and Cisco's pricing page. Duo quotes in dollars, so a UK buyer should confirm the sterling figure and VAT with a reseller before budgeting.
Features and administration
Where Microsoft is strong
The Entra ID plans bundle a lot more than MFA. Microsoft's plan comparison shows P1 including MFA, Conditional Access, single sign-on and advanced reports, while P2 adds Identity Protection, risk-based Conditional Access and Privileged Identity Management. If you are already paying for Microsoft 365, you are building on tools you may already own.
For tenants on the Free tier of Entra ID, security defaults prompt users for MFA when needed, though you cannot write your own rules. That is a reasonable floor for a tiny business, and a poor ceiling for one that needs exceptions for contractors or shared mailboxes.

Where Duo is strong
Duo's appeal is breadth. It is built to sit in front of many things at once: Microsoft 365, a VPN, a Linux server, a line-of-business app. Directory sync from Active Directory comes with Essentials, Advantage and Premier. Premier's network gateway gives remote access to private resources without a VPN. Independent reviewers mention fast implementation and ease of use as Duo's strengths.
Phishing resistance
Both platforms support phishing-resistant FIDO2/WebAuthn sign-in, according to a 2026 SMB guide to MFA tools. Whichever you choose, the practical advice is the same: a security key or passkey beats a push prompt, and a push prompt beats a text message. If you only enable one method, you are leaving a gap; Microsoft itself says to enable more than one for recovery.
Can you use them together?
This is the question behind several searches, and the answer has two halves.
Duo with Microsoft 365: yes. Duo integrates as an external MFA provider for Entra ID, so users see a Duo prompt when logging in to Microsoft 365 while still satisfying your Conditional Access policies. One limit worth knowing: Duo commercial and Duo Federal Moderate plans cannot connect to Microsoft GCC High environments, which matters to US government contractors rather than most UK SMEs.
Microsoft Authenticator with Duo: not as a swap. Cisco's own community answer states that other authenticator apps are not supported with Duo for Windows Logon; you need Duo Mobile. Microsoft's support community says much the same from the other side: Duo is a third-party authenticator and not something Microsoft manages. Practically, a user who protects both systems will carry both apps.
That is a hidden cost of mixing: two enrolment journeys, two sets of lost-phone requests, and two places to check when someone says "I can't sign in". If you do mix, document who owns what.
What it costs a UK small business
Take a 25-person firm as a worked example, using only the published list prices.
- Microsoft route: basic MFA is included in Microsoft 365 at no extra cost. If you need Conditional Access, Entra ID P1 at £5.40 per user per month comes to £135 a month, or £1,620 a year, for 25 users, before VAT. Many firms already have P1 through Microsoft 365 Business Premium, which includes it.
- Duo route: 25 users on Essentials at $3 each is $75 a month, or $900 a year, before VAT and exchange rates. Advantage at $6 would be $150 a month. Above 10 users the free tier no longer applies.
The numbers are close at this size, so cost rarely decides it. What decides it is whether you are paying for something you already own. One UK Microsoft consultant argues that for many small firms, higher-tier Entra features such as entitlement management are overkill compared with the MFA already in Business Premium. On the Duo side, reviewers note that pricing can be prohibitive for smaller teams and some users need training.
Disadvantages to weigh
Microsoft Authenticator and Entra ID
- Tied to the Microsoft ecosystem. It works best when most of your apps sign in through Entra ID.
- Conditional Access is powerful but unforgiving. Misconfigured rules can lock users out, including administrators, so always keep a tested emergency-access account.
- Good features sit behind licences. The jump from basic MFA to Conditional Access means P1.
Duo
- A second vendor, a second bill and a second app for staff.
- Dollar pricing and a free tier that stops at 10 users.
- If you are fully on Microsoft 365, you may pay for capabilities you can already switch on.
Neither is a bad choice. The failure we see more often is neither: MFA bought but only partly enforced, with exceptions for "just this one account" that quietly become permanent.
Which one should you choose?
Use this as a decision shortcut.
- Almost everything is Microsoft 365, and you have under 50 staff. Use Authenticator with Entra ID. It is, in the words of one 2026 SMB guide, the path of least resistance for Microsoft-centric organisations. Turn on Conditional Access if you hold P1.
- You have a VPN, Linux servers or many non-Microsoft apps. Duo suits mixed estates and offers quick rollout, so it deserves a trial. Use the 30-day trial before committing.
- Fewer than 10 users and a tight budget. Both are free to start: Microsoft's built-in MFA or Duo Free. Pick the one that matches the tools you use daily.
- You need to prove controls to a customer or insurer. Pick whichever you can enforce consistently and evidence clearly. A well-run Microsoft setup beats a half-deployed premium product.
- You are a sole practitioner such as a coach or consultant. The same logic applies at a smaller scale, and there are plain-language guides such as this one on MFA for coaches if you want a practitioner-sized view.
If you are on Microsoft 365 and unsure how well it is configured, our write-up on a Microsoft 365 security assessment shows what a proper review covers, from Secure Score to a CREST-style test.
How to roll out MFA without locking yourself out
Whichever product you pick, the sequence matters more than the logo.
- Inventory your sign-ins. List email, file storage, VPN, remote desktop, admin portals and any supplier systems.
- Protect administrators first. Admin accounts are the ones attackers want. Enrol them before anyone else.
- Enable at least two methods per user. An app plus a hardware key or a backup method avoids a flood of lost-phone tickets.
- Pilot with a small group. Ten people for a week will reveal old email clients and shared accounts that break.
- Create an emergency-access account. Store it offline and test it. This is your answer to a bad Conditional Access rule.
- Enforce, then review. Check sign-in reports monthly for legacy logins that bypass MFA.
If you want an outside check that MFA really covers every route in, an external IP test will show which internet-facing services still accept a password alone.
Where Solusec fits

We do not sell MFA licences, which is why we can say plainly that either route works when it is configured well. What we do is test and certify the result. As a CREST-accredited firm, we run penetration tests where you speak directly to the testers rather than a sales team. Our published prices start at £2,500 for a CMS website test and £3,000 for an external IP test. For certification, Cyber Essentials runs from £320 to £600 depending on organisation size, a gap analysis is £300, and urgent turnaround is an extra £100.
If you are choosing MFA because a customer, a school trust or a funder has asked for Cyber Essentials, begin with the Cyber Essentials gap analysis so you know what to fix before the assessment. If you want to know whether your set-up holds against a real attacker, see our CREST penetration testing.

Not sure where you stand? Talk to the Solusec team about a proportionate review of your sign-in security. If you already know you want certification, the Cyber Essentials page has the packages and the urgent option. Wondering whether your business needs it at all? Our guide on whether a small business needs Cyber Essentials covers it.
FAQ
Can I use Duo with Microsoft 365?
Yes. Duo can act as an external MFA provider for Microsoft Entra ID, so Microsoft 365 sign-ins show a Duo prompt while still meeting your Conditional Access requirements. You configure it in your Entra tenant and in the Duo admin panel. Check Duo's current documentation for licensing requirements before you start.
Can I use Microsoft Authenticator instead of Duo Mobile?
Not for Duo's own integrations. Cisco states that authenticator apps other than Duo Mobile are not supported with Duo for Windows Logon. Users who are protected by both systems will normally keep both apps installed.
Is Duo the same as Azure MFA?
No. Azure MFA is the former name of Microsoft's MFA, now part of Microsoft Entra ID. Duo is a separate Cisco product. Both do the same basic job of adding a second proof of identity, but they differ in pricing, administration and the range of systems they protect.
What are the disadvantages of Microsoft Authenticator?
The app itself is simple, but it works best inside the Microsoft ecosystem, and advanced controls need Entra ID P1 or P2 licences. Poorly designed Conditional Access rules can lock users out. Enrol more than one method per person so a lost phone does not stop someone working.
Sources
- About Microsoft Authenticator, Microsoft Support
- Deployment considerations for Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication
- Cisco Duo
- Duo editions and pricing
- Microsoft Entra ID, Microsoft Security (UK)
- Microsoft Entra plans and pricing (UK)
- Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication, Microsoft Security (UK)
- Per-user Microsoft Entra MFA and security defaults
- Duo Directory Sync from Active Directory
- Duo two-factor authentication for Microsoft Entra ID
- Cisco Community: Can I use Microsoft Authenticator with Duo?
- Microsoft Q&A: DUO authenticator
- Duo Security review, SpotSaaS
- Best MFA tools for PCI DSS compliance, 2026 SMB guide
- Microsoft Entra ID P2 entitlement management: an honest assessment for SMBs
- MFA voor coaches, Exantur
Recommended
- Sophos vs Bitdefender: which is right for a UK SME?
- Veeam vs Acronis: Which Backup Suits a UK SME?
- SentinelOne vs CrowdStrike: Which EDR Suits a UK SME?
- 5 Actions This Week for UK Small Business Cyber Security
This article was created with assistance of AI. We never use AI with your data unless given explicit permission.
